Thank you, Donna Hay
I made pecan pie for Thanksgiving dinner this year. I made one last year, too, when I was in Australia for Thanksgiving. My neighbors made a special Thanksgiving dinner for me with a turkey that looked like what real turkeys once looked like. And I made pecan pie the year before and the one before that. My husband loves pecan pie and I love him, so I make it on Thanksgiving, at Christmas and for his birthday.
I think of my great-grandmother as I measure the corn syrup, sugar, eggs, vanilla, a dollop of molasses and a pinch or two of ground coriander into her dimpled brown and ochre earthenware bowl. She didn’t cook. She supervised, but she knew recipes and the bowl belonged to her. She loved the southern food of her youth, and pecan pie is definitely sweet sensuous southern food — crunchy pecans as counterpoint to the sweet gelatinous swirl of sugar and eggs.
I often make my own crust and did this year too. I pulled down the flour from the cupboard, measured it carefully, cut in the shortening, sprinkled on the water, and cut and recut the dough until it was bonded and layered. It was a bit more elastic than usual, but I hardly noticed in the delight of having a grown daughter home for a holiday, and the flurry of family conversation.
I determinedly overcame the dough’s tendency to retract, firmly rolling it out from the center mound until I had a large enough circle to fit into my porcelain quiche dish – it’s an eclectic kitchen in my home, bits of this relative’s kitchen and bits of that one. The quiche dish works fine for pecan pie, since the pie tin has become a dog food dish.
I crimped the edges and filled in the rips in the bottom and thought about how flaky my pie crusts are, and how I was looking forward to the smile on my husband’s face when he bit into the pecan pie. I sprayed the bottom of the crust with Pam which seems to inhibit soggy crust. I added the pecans to the filling, poured the ingredients from the earthenware bowl into the pie shell and put it in the oven to bake.
When I bake a berry pie, I often put a pan underneath to catch any escaping juices, but I don’t need one for a pecan pie because the filling always stays put and domes to tell me when the pie is finished baking.
After an hour, I checked to see how the pie was coming along. To my surprise, this pecan pie filling had overflowed. I was sure I had measured the ingredients properly as I know those Karo syrup folks have a good recipe on the side of their corn syrup bottle. The pie was not domed, so I left it to bake another 20 minutes or so until I could tell the pecans were well toasted. I wiped out the oven so the roast potatoes could bake next and set the pie aside to cool.
As the mother of grown children, I’ve learned to put tidbits of information together into a whole story — a look here, a dropped detail there, and pretty soon you have a whole picture. Not necessarily entirely accurate, but the drift, nonetheless.
I’d unknowingly gathered the first kernel of information that would develop into the big pecan-pie picture –stored in the “ephemera, etc.” file in my overloaded brain.
The family accoutrements gleamed on a table more formally dressed than we were. Our sweats had been upgraded to slacks. Guests arrived, wine opened, and eventually the turkey my husband bakes in the kettle barbecue emerged smelling fabulous and looking succulent. The drippings were carefully carried to the stove, ready to flavor the gravy. I pulled the flour from the cupboard and made a roux as my mother had taught me decades ago. I added broth from the boiled giblets and whisked the gravy smooth, ready to place in the wok-pan I use to make gravy. Eclectic kitchen, as I mentioned.
I just happened to notice that the flour in my hand was self-rising flour and not my usual flour at all. I pushed aside the cornmeal and granola, looking for plain flour. My stomach dropped. The plain flour sack was almost empty – no more than two tablespoons left, far short of what I needed for the base for gravy.
Now, normally I wouldn’t have self-rising flour in my cupboard in the US at all. Americans like to add baking powder, salt and soda to their flour to aid rising, but Australians consider self-rising flour, with the rising agent already added, a staple for baking.
I’ve become a fan of the well-designed cookbooks of Australian food stylist Donna Hay
and the interesting dishes she and her team offer. I had made a Peach and Raspberry Tart from her cookbook Off the Shelf that required the self-rising flour just a couple of weeks before. Friends served us this aromatic tart at dinner, and I’ve followed their example several times. Guests ask for seconds.
With no recourse left for gravy-making, I used the self-rising flour to make my base roux. I didn’t want the gravy to start raising in the gravy boat – a culinary adventure I was hoping to avoid — so I boiled the gravy thoroughly, adding the flavorful pan drippings and stock from the giblets, whisking the mixture all the while. Oh, that gravy was divine on the roasted potatoes and cauliflower, and well-behaved in its serving boat, too.
At last the pecan pie made its entrance, along side a superb 4-inch tall pumpkin cheesecake with pecan crust and sour cream icing baked by a guest and unwrapped from its metal collar just before serving. I cut the pie, liberating it with some difficulty from the crusted sides of the pan and served small slices to each guest along with the perfect cheesecake. I slid into my chair, and as hostess invited everyone to enjoy the desserts.
My slice of pecan pie had an odd crust. It was arched in the middle of the slice rather than flat on the bottom, floating, as it were, in the middle of the pie – a perfect back-bend where none was called for. It wasn’t until that first bite that I put together the second kernel of information in the big pecan-pie picture: that the self-rising flour I’d discovered in my hand during gravy making must have been the same flour I’d used to make the piecrust.
Alarm bells went off in my head as I examined not a tasty flaky crust, but an odd pita-bread crust, even pizza-like in its consistency. Not a crust in the bottom of the pan holding gelatinous sweetness, but something in the middle distance, pecans crusted to the top, slightly over-baked. And underneath the bottom crust where none should be, the filling — a strange sticky substance that had congealed into rubberized glue.
Like a fledgling osprey pushing siblings from the nest, this self-rising pie crust had somehow not only risen like dough, but floated into the pie itself, pushing the contents from the pie plate onto the oven floor and leaving the rest of the filling to ooze underneath the so-called crust to over-bake into taffy.
I didn’t even have the nerve to glance at my husband to see the disappointment in his eyes. He’d have to wait to Christmas to sample his favorite pecan pie. I relieved my guests of any obligation to sample even the smallest bite and was grateful for the delicious perfection of the pumpkin cheesecake.
I lay my disastrous pecan pie this Thanksgiving directly at Donna Hay’s feet. I wouldn’t have had self-rising flour in my cupboard in the States except for her delicious recipe which I had NOT made that day. Thank you, Donna Hay.
***
From Off the Shelf by Donna Hay (p.155) with author’s notes
Peach and Raspberry Tart
Ingredients:
125 g (4 oz. butter =1 stick)), softened
1 cup caster (superfine or baker’s) sugar
1 tsp vanilla extract
2 eggs, room temperature
1 ½ cups self-raising (self-rising) flour, sifted
2 peaches, halved, cut into thin wedges (nectarines are good, frozen OK too)
150 g (5 oz) raspberries (any berries or combination of berries in season work, frozen OK too.) See notes below.
2 TBS icing (confectioner’s/powdered) sugar
*1 tsp ground coriander mixed into filling (author’s option)
Directions:
1. Preheat oven to 160º C, 325º F. (I’ve kicked mine up to 350º F with success. See Note below.)
2. Line a 22 cm (9 inch) round cake tin with a removable base with baking paper.
3. Place the butter, sugar, coriander, and vanilla in a bowl and beat until light and creamy.
4. Add the eggs and beat well.
5. Fold in the flour and spoon the mixture into the lined tin.
6. Top with peaches and raspberries (or other fruit mix — see below).
7. Sprinkle with icing (confectioner’s/powdered) sugar.
8. Bake for 1 hour or until the tart is cooked when tested with a skewer. (I’ve found this can be up to 1.5 hours at 350º. See Note below.)
9. Remove from tin to cool. Remove baking paper to serve.
*Can serve warm with ice cream or at room temperature with whipped cream, or crème fraîche (as in photo), or even by itself warm or cool. Serves 8-10.
Note: I’ve found the cooking times for some of Donna Hay’s baked recipes
perfect when I’m in Australia with my fan-assisted oven, but short for my conventional American oven. Test with a skewer in the center to make sure the tart is done. The skewer will emerge clean if the tart is done, with dough clinging to it if it is underdone.
And: I’ve used more fruit with my tarts, including 1.5 cups rhubarb set aside before I start the batter with 2 Tbs sugar to start the juices flowing. I mixed in blueberries and frozen raspberries to make about 2 cups fruit. The juice drips deep into the tart, changing the focus from cake to fruit. You can also use a mix of fresh and frozen fruit.
***
For more information:
Donna Hay’s website: www.donnahay.com.au
For access to her cookbooks and magazine in the States: http://www.amazon.com
For access to her cookbooks and magazine in Australia: http://www.dymocks.com.au
For the classic PECAN PIE recipe from Karo Syrup (note for Aussie cooks — substitute brown syrup. Works perfectly): http://www.karosyrup.com/pecanPie.asp. Remember, use regular flour, not self-rising, if you make your own crust!